Kelly is a 1983 Catholic Central graduate and a Ted Sowle Award winner selected as the most outstanding male athlete in his class. He was voted All-City in football, basketball and baseball his senior year and was All-Area in football as well. In basketball as a senior, Kelly served as team captain and led the team in scoring and rebounding.
Spielmaker attended Western Michigan University and was a 4-year starter for the Bronco football team. He was voted Freshman of the year in the Mid-American Conference, player of the week on several occasions, and All-Conference during his career. Kelly is the all-time leader in receiving yards for Bronco tight-ends.
Kelly now resides in Florida where he lives with his college sweetheart, Lisa. They have been married 33 years and have 3 sons; Connor, Logan and Christian. Kelly is Sales Manager for Greenway Landscape Supply in Naples, Florida.